Mild Cheddar

Our Mild Cheddar is an award-winner! Handcrafted and aged one to three months to deliver a mild tangy flavor. It slices and grates easily, making for a perfect grilled sandwich.

2nd Place: 2020 World Championship Cheese Contest – Traditional Waxed Cheddar, Mild to Medium category

Natural Mild Cheddar Cheese

Product Description: Natural Mild Cheddar Cheese has a creamy, buttery flavor. It’s less sharp than its aged counterparts, making it more approachable and versatile. The texture is smooth and semi-firm, offering moderate richness and creaminess.

Pairings and Complementary Flavors:

Cocktails: White Russian, Whiskey Sour, Gin and Tonic, Old Fashioned, Apple Cider Cocktail
~ The smooth profile of a White Russian pairs well with the creamy texture of the cheese for a harmonious pairing.
~ The citrusy tang in a Whiskey Sour complements the cheese flavors, while the clean, herbal notes of a Gin and Tonic cut through the cheddar’s richness.
~ The sweetness and aromatic bitters in an Old Fashioned balance the cheddar’s mildness, while a spiced Apple Cider Cocktail makes for an intriguing duo.

Wine: Pinot Grigio, Red Zinfandel, Cabernet Sauvignon, Chardonnay, Riesling
~ Crisp Pinot Grigio complements the creaminess of mild cheddar without overwhelming its subtle flavors.
~ The red berry flavors of Red Zinfandel accentuate the buttery creaminess of mild cheddar.
~ Cabernet Sauvignon offers bold fruit flavors and tannins that stand up to the cheese without overpowering it.
~ A lightly oaked Chardonnay highlights the cheddar’s creamy qualities, while a dry or off-dry Riesling is a nice contrast with its acidity and light fruity notes.

Beer: Pale Ale, Wheat beer, Pilsner, Amber Ale, Stout
~ The balanced bitter and malt taste of Pale Ale complements the creaminess of mild cheddar.
~ A light and refreshing Wheat Beer brings out the richness of mild cheddar.
~ Pilsner’s crisp and light hop bitterness cuts through the richness and makes for a balanced pairing.
~ The caramel and malty flavor of Amber Ale will enhance the mild qualities of the cheese.
~ A milk or oatmeal Stout offers a creamy texture with chocolate or coffee notes that match well with the creaminess of mild cheddar to make a harmonious pairing.

Accompaniments: fruits, nuts, pickles, olives, jam, chutney, mustard, honey, hot sauce
~ Apples, pears, and grapes offer a sweet contrast to the cheese’s flavor profile.
~ Almonds, walnuts, or pecans contribute a contrasting crunchy texture and nutty taste that pairs well with it.
~ Pickles and olives offer a salty tang.
~ Fruit-based jam or spicy chutney provides a sweet and tangy contrast, while stone ground mustard, honey, or hot sauce can add another layer of flavor when served alongside mild cheddar.

Suggested uses:

• A flavorful choice for grilled cheese sandwiches, macaroni and cheese, burgers, pizza, omelets, frittatas, potato dishes, salads, pasta, and casseroles
• It brings a creamy element to soups, sauces, and dips 
• Adds a tasty twist to homemade savory bread, muffins, and scones